When searching for stream deck alternatives for macro control, the key challenge is balancing features, affordability, and ease of use. The Elgato Stream Deck MK.2 remains the overall leader thanks to its intuitive LCD keys and reliable software. However, options like the VSDINSIDE Macro Keypad excel in offering more programmable keys at a lower price, while the ActionRing Stream Controller provides versatile dials and a compact form factor for creative workflows. Buyers must weigh factors like customization, build quality, and compatibility, as tradeoffs often involve fewer keys or higher costs. Continue reading for a detailed breakdown of each option’s strengths and weaknesses.
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- The number of programmable keys significantly impacts macro control flexibility, with larger keypads suited for complex workflows.
- LCD integration enhances visual feedback but often comes with a higher price tag and increased complexity.
- Build quality and software reliability are top priorities for a seamless streaming or gaming experience.
- Compact designs work well for limited desk space, though they may sacrifice key quantity or features.
- Compatibility with streaming platforms and operating systems varies, so check support before purchasing.
| Elgato Stream Deck MK.2 Studio Controller with 15 LCD Macro Keys |  | Best Overall for Versatility and Visual Feedback | Keys: 15 customizable LCD macro keys | Operation: One-touch single or multi-action control | Feedback: Visual command confirmation | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Streonor S15 Standard Stream Controller, Black |  | Best for Extensive Customization and System Monitoring | Number of Keys: 15 | Status Display Panels: 3 | Compatibility: Windows 10 64-bit or higher, macOS Big Sur 11.0+ | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| ActionRing Stream Controller Deck, Macro Keypad, Gaming Shortcut Keyboard, 6 Customizable LCD Keys, 3 Dials |  | Best for Compact Multi-Function Control with Dials | Number of keys: 6 | Number of dials: 3 | Compatibility: Windows, macOS | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| VSDINSIDE Macro Keypad, Stream Controller Deck with 18 Programmable Keys for Gaming and Streaming |  | Best for High Key Count and Macro Flexibility | Number of Keys: 18 | Display Type: LCD visual keys | Connectivity: USB-C | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Mini Stream Controller Deck, Gaming Streaming Macro Pad with 6 Programmable LCD Keys, RGB Lighting, USB Soundboard for Video Editing, OBS, PC, Mac |  | Best Compact for Basic Macro Control and Video Tasks | Number of Keys: 6 | Key Type: LCD Programmable Keys | Lighting: RGB Light with Dual Light Bars | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| ULANZI Stream Controller Macro Keyboard D200 U-Studio Macro Pad with 14 LCD Keys |  | Best for Customization and System Monitoring | Number of Keys: 14 | Connectivity Technology: USB | Compatible Devices: Mac, PC, Windows | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| FIFINE AmpliGame D6 Stream Controller with 15 Customizable LCD Macro Keys |  | Best for Platform Integration and Visual Feedback | Model: AmpliGame D6 | Macro Keys: 15 customizable LCD keys | Compatibility: Mac and PC | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| VSD N4 Pro Macro Pad Stream Controller – Programmable LCD Keys, Soundboard & Audio Mixer for Streaming, Gaming, OBS, PC & Mac |  | Best for Multi-Functionality and Advanced Customization | Keys: 10 customizable LCD keys | Knobs: 4 RGB knobs | Touch Bar: Interactive | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| stream deck alternatives for macro control | Compatibility | Number of Keys | Lighting |
|---|---|---|---|
| Elgato Stream Deck MK.2 Studio | Mac and PC | — | — |
| Streonor S15 Standard Stream C | Windows 10 64-bit or higher, macOS Big Sur 11.0+ | 15 | — |
| ActionRing Stream Controller D | Windows, macOS | 6 | — |
| VSDINSIDE Macro Keypad | Windows 11+, macOS 11.0+ | 18 | RGB surround light ring |
| Mini Stream Controller Deck | Windows, macOS, Linux | 6 | RGB Light with Dual Light Bars |
| ULANZI Stream Controller Macro | — | 14 | — |
| FIFINE AmpliGame D6 Stream Con | Mac and PC | — | Customizable RGB ring |
| VSD N4 Pro Macro Pad Stream Co | Windows 10+ and macOS 11.0+ | — | RGB, supports GIF/MP4/MOV media |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Elgato Stream Deck MK.2 Studio Controller with 15 LCD Macro Keys
This model stands out for its large, customizable LCD keys that provide clear visual feedback, making it easier to manage complex workflows at a glance. Unlike the smaller Mini Stream Controller Deck, it offers a richer interface suitable for streamers who need quick access to multiple actions. Its support for a wide array of integrations, from OBS to Philips Hue, makes it a flexible choice for content creators who want a unified control surface. The main tradeoff is its limited 15 keys—if you require more shortcuts, you’ll need to consider alternatives like the VSDINSIDE Macro Keypad, which offers more keys but less visual feedback. This pick is ideal for users seeking a comprehensive macro control solution that balances customization with visual clarity.
Pros:- Large, customizable LCD keys provide visual clarity for quick action recognition
- Supports multiple app integrations including streaming platforms and smart home devices
- Compatible with both Mac and PC, ensuring flexibility across systems
Cons:- Limited to 15 keys, which may restrict workflows for advanced users
- Requires plugin setup and some configuration, which can be time-consuming
Best for: Streamers and content creators who need a versatile, visually intuitive control surface with broad app integration
Not ideal for: Power users requiring extensive macro keys beyond 15, or those on a tight budget who prefer DIY solutions
- Keys:15 customizable LCD macro keys
- Operation:One-touch single or multi-action control
- Feedback:Visual command confirmation
- Compatibility:Mac and PC
- Integrations:Elgato 4KCU, OBS, Twitch, YouTube, Twitter, Discord, Spotify, Philips Hue
- Use Cases:Streaming, film editing, music production, photography
Our verdict“This is best suited for streamers and content creators seeking a feature-rich, visually guided macro controller with broad compatibility.”
Streonor S15 Standard Stream Controller, Black
The Streonor S15 excels in offering extensive customization with its 15 LCD keys and 3 status display panels, making it well-suited for users who want both macro control and real-time system info. Compared with the VSDINSIDE Macro Keypad, the S15 provides dedicated status panels that serve as an at-a-glance system monitor, a feature that enhances workflow awareness. However, it lacks Linux support, unlike the Mini Stream Controller Deck, which broadens compatibility with various operating systems. Its broad plugin support and visual customization make it ideal for streamers who also need system feedback, but setup can be complex for less tech-savvy users. Overall, this is a solid choice for power users who want macro control combined with system monitoring.
Pros:- Includes 3 status display panels for real-time system monitoring
- Highly customizable with 15 LCD keys and plugin support
- Compatible with both Windows and Mac systems
Cons:- Lacks support for Linux systems, limiting flexibility
- Setup may require uninstalling conflicting software or configuring plugins
Best for: Streamers and productivity users needing macro control paired with real-time system status displays
Not ideal for: Linux users or those seeking a plug-and-play experience without complex setup
- Number of Keys:15
- Status Display Panels:3
- Compatibility:Windows 10 64-bit or higher, macOS Big Sur 11.0+
- Supported Plugins:100+
- Icon Support:Custom icons and GIFs
Our verdict“Ideal for users who want macro control combined with live system feedback and are comfortable with setup complexity.”
ActionRing Stream Controller Deck, Macro Keypad, Gaming Shortcut Keyboard, 6 Customizable LCD Keys, 3 Dials
The ActionRing Stream Controller Deck offers a unique combination of six LCD keys and three physical dials, making it well-suited for users who prefer tactile controls alongside visual macros. Compared with the Mini Stream Controller Deck, its inclusion of dials allows for more nuanced adjustments, especially useful in gaming or live editing scenarios. Its support for images and animations on keys enhances recognition but may require extra setup time. While the device is compatible with both Windows and macOS, the limited number of keys might restrict complex workflows—better suited for users who prefer quick, essential controls rather than extensive macro sets. This device shines for those needing a compact but flexible control surface with physical knobs.
Pros:- Includes 3 dials for precise adjustments alongside LCD keys
- Supports images and animations for easy identification
- Compatible with OBS, Twitch, YouTube, and Photoshop
Cons:- Limited to 6 keys, which may not suit complex macro needs
- Setup and configuration can be time-consuming for beginners
Best for: Gamers and streamers who favor a smaller footprint but want tactile control with visual and adjustable parameters
Not ideal for: Power users needing many macros or advanced workflows that demand more than 6 keys
- Number of keys:6
- Number of dials:3
- Compatibility:Windows, macOS
- Support:Images and animations on keys
- Warranty:24 months
Our verdict“Best for users seeking a compact, tactile macro control device with visual feedback and dials for nuanced adjustments.”
VSDINSIDE Macro Keypad, Stream Controller Deck with 18 Programmable Keys for Gaming and Streaming
The VSDINSIDE Macro Keypad stands out with its 18 programmable keys and LCD visual keys, offering ample space for complex macro setups. Compared to the Elgato Stream Deck MK.2, it provides more macro keys, making it suitable for users with extensive control needs. Its support for multi-shortcut macros and customizable RGB lighting enhances workflow and aesthetic appeal, especially in dim environments. However, it lacks native Linux support and requires a firmware upgrade for custom RGB tones, which could be inconvenient for some users. Its broad compatibility with Windows and macOS makes it a versatile choice for streamers and professionals who need a high key count and visual macro management, but setup may be more involved for advanced configurations.
Pros:- High 18 key count allows detailed macro and shortcut setup
- Supports multi-shortcut macros for workflow efficiency
- RGB lighting enhances visibility and aesthetics
Cons:- No native Linux support, limiting cross-platform flexibility
- Requires firmware updates for custom RGB tones, adding setup complexity
Best for: Content creators and gamers needing many programmable keys for detailed macro control and visual customization
Not ideal for: Linux users or those seeking a plug-and-play device without firmware upgrades or complex setup
- Number of Keys:18
- Display Type:LCD visual keys
- Connectivity:USB-C
- Compatibility:Windows 11+, macOS 11.0+
- Lighting:RGB surround light ring
- Built-in Plugins:Schedule reminder, clock, stopwatch, weather, calendar
Our verdict“Ideal for power users who need a high number of macros with visual feedback and are comfortable handling firmware updates.”
Mini Stream Controller Deck, Gaming Streaming Macro Pad with 6 Programmable LCD Keys, RGB Lighting, USB Soundboard for Video Editing, OBS, PC, Mac
The Mini Stream Controller Deck offers a compact solution with 6 LCD keys, making it suitable for users with limited space or simple macro needs. Compared with larger devices like the VSDINSIDE Macro Keypad, it’s more portable but less capable of handling complex workflows. Its broad system compatibility, including Linux, is a plus for flexible setups, yet its limited key count restricts its use for users who need extensive shortcut access. The RGB lighting adds aesthetic value, but setup involves software installation, and the device needs continuous USB power. This makes it a strong choice for casual streamers or those who want a small, reliable macro pad for basic tasks.
Pros:- Compact and durable design fits small desks and setups
- Supports visual icons and animations on LCD keys
- Broad compatibility including Linux systems
Cons:- Limited to 6 keys, which may not suit more complex workflows
- Requires software installation and constant USB connection
Best for: Streamers, gamers, and professionals seeking a small, portable macro pad for basic shortcuts and quick access
Not ideal for: Power users or workflows requiring many macros or advanced automation
- Number of Keys:6
- Key Type:LCD Programmable Keys
- Lighting:RGB Light with Dual Light Bars
- Compatibility:Windows, macOS, Linux
- Connection:USB
- Software Required:VSD Craft software
Our verdict“Best for users needing a small, portable macro pad for basic control and quick shortcuts in limited space.”
ULANZI Stream Controller Macro Keyboard D200 U-Studio Macro Pad with 14 LCD Keys
The ULANZI D200 stands out for its highly customizable macro keys combined with a built-in LCD display, allowing quick access to frequently used commands and real-time system monitoring. Compared with the VSD N4 Pro, which offers more keys and additional features like an interactive touch bar, the D200 keeps things simpler but still effective for content creators requiring straightforward macro control. Its 14 keys are suitable for users who prefer focused, easy-to-navigate setups but may fall short for streamers needing extensive button arrays. The LCD display enhances usability by showing key statuses, making it a good middle ground between basic macro pads and more complex control surfaces. However, its limited number of keys and lack of wireless options could restrict some workflows. This pick makes the most sense for creators who want a compact, customizable macro pad with system monitoring capabilities.
Pros:- Highly customizable macro keys with an LCD display for quick access
- Supports real-time CPU/GPU monitoring, ideal for streamers
- Plug-and-play compatibility with Windows and Mac systems
Cons:- Limited to 14 keys, which may be insufficient for more complex workflows
- Requires USB connection, limiting portability
- No wireless or Bluetooth support
Best for: Content creators and streamers needing customizable macro control with real-time system feedback
Not ideal for: Users seeking a large macro surface or wireless functionality, as the D200 is limited to USB and 14 keys
- Number of Keys:14
- Connectivity Technology:USB
- Compatible Devices:Mac, PC, Windows
- Additional Features:Multiuse, Live CPU/GPU Monitor
- Power Source:USB Powered
- Color:Black
Our verdict“Best suited for users who want a compact, customizable macro pad with system monitoring features.”
FIFINE AmpliGame D6 Stream Controller with 15 Customizable LCD Macro Keys
The FIFINE AmpliGame D6 excels through its 15 LCD macro keys, supporting visual shortcuts and feedback, making it well-suited for streamers and gamers who want seamless interaction with OBS, Streamlabs, and other platforms. Unlike the ULANZI D200, which emphasizes system monitoring, the D6 is designed for full platform integration, with support for popular streaming tools and downloadable plugins. Its RGB lighting and folders add aesthetic appeal and organizational flexibility, but initial setup and firmware updates can be somewhat cumbersome. The D6’s focus on platform compatibility and visual cues makes it ideal for those who prioritize aesthetic customization and visual feedback over system monitoring. However, it lacks a touch screen or advanced multi-action macros, limiting its complexity for highly intricate workflows. This option makes the most sense for streamers who want visual feedback and platform integration in a macro control device.
Pros:- 15 customizable LCD keys offer visual shortcuts and feedback
- Supports popular streaming platforms and downloadable plugins
- Customizable RGB lighting with nine modes enhances aesthetics
Cons:- Firmware and software may require updates before use
- Full functionality demands setup and customization, which may be time-consuming
Best for: Streamers and gamers needing platform-specific shortcuts with visual feedback
Not ideal for: Users seeking extensive system monitoring or advanced multi-step macros, as setup can be time-consuming
- Model:AmpliGame D6
- Macro Keys:15 customizable LCD keys
- Compatibility:Mac and PC
- Supported Platforms:OBS Studio, Streamlabs, Twitch, YouTube
- Lighting:Customizable RGB ring
- RGB Modes:9
Our verdict“Ideal for streamers who value platform integration and visual cues over extensive macro complexity.”
VSD N4 Pro Macro Pad Stream Controller – Programmable LCD Keys, Soundboard & Audio Mixer for Streaming, Gaming, OBS, PC & Mac
The VSD N4 Pro offers a versatile setup with 10 LCD keys, 4 RGB knobs, and an interactive touch bar, making it suitable for users who want more than just macro control. Its ability to activate multi-step macros with a single tap, combined with a built-in USB soundboard and over 500 downloadable plugins, elevates it above simpler devices like the ULANZI D200 or FIFINE D6. The inclusion of an ergonomic foldable stand and cross-platform support enhances usability during long sessions, although the absence of built-in speakers and reliance on plugins for full feature access could be limiting for some. Its multi-functionality as an audio mixer and macro controller makes it a strong choice for content creators who need an all-in-one device. The tradeoff involves a steeper learning curve and dependency on plugin downloads for expanding features. This pick is ideal for power users who want a multi-purpose, highly customizable macro device.
Pros:- Supports multi-step macros with a single tap, no coding needed
- Functions as a USB soundboard with 500+ plugins for extensive customization
- Includes ergonomic foldable stand and cross-platform support
Cons:- No built-in speakers, only sends audio commands
- Full feature set depends on downloading and configuring plugins, which can be complex
Best for: Advanced streamers, gamers, and content creators seeking multi-functionality and extensive customization
Not ideal for: Beginners or users with limited space, due to its feature set and setup complexity
- Keys:10 customizable LCD keys
- Knobs:4 RGB knobs
- Touch Bar:Interactive
- Plugin Ecosystem:500+ downloadable plugins
- Lighting:RGB, supports GIF/MP4/MOV media
- Compatibility:Windows 10+ and macOS 11.0+
Our verdict“Best suited for tech-savvy users needing a multifunctional macro controller and audio mixer in one device.”
How We Picked
Products were evaluated based on their programmability, build quality, compatibility, ease of use, and value for money. Priority was given to devices that offered a balance of features suitable for both gaming and streaming, with an emphasis on intuitive software and durable construction. Devices with extensive customization options and reliable performance ranked higher, while those with limited keys or inconsistent software were rated lower. Our goal was to highlight options that serve a range of needs, from beginners to advanced users, ensuring each choice offers a clear advantage in macro control capabilities.| stream deck alternatives for macro control | Compatibility | Lighting |
|---|---|---|
| Elgato Stream Deck MK.2 Studio | Mac and PC | — |
| Streonor S15 Standard Stream C | Windows 10 64-bit or higher, macOS Big Sur 11.0+ | — |
| ActionRing Stream Controller D | Windows, macOS | — |
| VSDINSIDE Macro Keypad | Windows 11+, macOS 11.0+ | RGB surround light ring |
| Mini Stream Controller Deck | Windows, macOS, Linux | RGB Light with Dual Light Bars |
| ULANZI Stream Controller Macro | — | — |
| FIFINE AmpliGame D6 Stream Con | Mac and PC | Customizable RGB ring |
| VSD N4 Pro Macro Pad Stream Co | Windows 10+ and macOS 11.0+ | RGB, supports GIF/MP4/MOV media |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Stream Deck Alternatives For Macro Control
Choosing the right macro control device involves several key factors that can significantly influence your streaming or gaming setup. Beyond just the number of keys, consider how easy it is to customize, the quality of construction, and platform compatibility. Paying attention to these details helps prevent common pitfalls like software incompatibility or insufficient expandability, which can hinder long-term use. Here are the main factors to keep in mind:Number of Keys and Expandability
Assess how many macro keys you need now and in the future. Larger keypads or those with expandability options provide more room for customization as your workflow evolves. However, more keys often mean a higher cost and larger footprint. Consider your typical use case—if you primarily need a few shortcuts, a smaller device could suffice, but if you handle complex commands, prioritize models with ample keys or expansion options.
Software Compatibility and Ease of Customization
The software supporting your macro device should be intuitive and reliable. Some brands offer extensive customization features, while others may have clunky interfaces or limited platform support. Check whether the device supports your operating system and streaming platforms. A well-designed app reduces setup time and helps you fine-tune macros effortlessly, saving frustration during live sessions.
Build Quality and Durability
A device with sturdy construction ensures longevity, especially if you frequently press keys or travel with your setup. Look for models with high-quality materials and positive user reviews regarding durability. Cheaper plastic builds may wear out quickly, leading to malfunction or inconsistent responses, which can disrupt your workflow or streaming quality.
Form Factor and Desk Space
Consider how much space you have available and whether a compact or larger device suits your setup. Smaller controllers are easier to integrate into tight spaces but may limit the number of macros. Larger models provide more keys and features but can clutter your desk. Balance your spatial constraints with your need for macro control to find the best fit.
Additional Features (Display, Dials, Sound Integration)
Extras like LCD screens, rotary dials, or soundboards can enhance functionality, giving real-time feedback or additional control layers. LCD keys are particularly helpful for identifying macros quickly, but they increase cost and complexity. Decide which features are essential for your workflow—overloading on unnecessary extras might complicate setup without real benefit.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use these alternatives with streaming platforms like Twitch or YouTube?
Most of these macro control devices support popular streaming platforms like Twitch and YouTube through compatible software or plugins. Ensure the device’s software integrates well with your streaming setup, and check for platform-specific features. Compatibility varies, so reviewing user feedback on platform support can prevent surprises during live sessions.
Are these devices suitable for gaming or only for streaming?
Many of these macro controllers are designed to serve both gamers and streamers, offering customizable keys for in-game commands and streaming shortcuts. Devices with additional features like dials or soundboards can enhance gaming control, while others focus on stream management. Choose one based on your primary use—some models excel in both areas, but others are optimized for one purpose.
Is it worth paying extra for LCD keys or additional features?
LCD keys and extra features can improve workflow efficiency by providing visual feedback and quick access to macros. However, they often come at a higher price and may introduce complexity. If you manage many macros or need dynamic feedback, investing in these features makes sense. For simpler setups, a basic keypad might suffice, saving money without sacrificing functionality.
How important is build quality compared to features?
Build quality directly impacts device longevity and reliability, especially during intense sessions. While feature-rich models are appealing, a poorly constructed device can malfunction or wear out quickly. Prioritize sturdy materials and positive user reviews on durability, especially if you plan to use the device frequently or transport it regularly.
Can I customize these devices for specific software like OBS or gaming platforms?
Most of these macro controllers support customization for specific software like OBS, Twitch, or gaming titles through dedicated apps or profiles. Compatibility varies, so verify whether the device offers pre-made profiles or flexible customization options for your preferred platform. This flexibility helps streamline your workflow and ensures quick macro execution during live sessions.
